Tower Designs

[IIIiNSANiTyIII]

I am in the process of re-building the entrance into our Dwarven build of Torhyeir. I began by building a tower and found myself with three different designs.

Im here to ask opinions.

Keep in mind that this is a dwarven build, and I would like to maintain a style as such

-IIIiNSANiTyIII

 

[Terence29]

As a dwarven build, I suggest Nr. 2. It does not have a wooden roof, and so would fit to a dwarven mountain base, in my opinion.

 

[AussieDog2012]

I like 3, but to me, the pointed roof sticks out to much to be believable and lacks detail. I think if you just played around with that a bit it would look fantastic

 

[Celeras]

I like 3, but I would add a steeple in the center.

 

[Th3_Drunk_Monk]

3!

 

[PenPad]

personally i like 3 the best but 2 is also nice

 

[thor5648]

1 is kind of like wizardish, 2 is more castle/human style, 3 is definatly looking more towards the dwarf style. My opinion.

 

[krios41]

i think one is a big no, teh second one looks like a guard tower to me and teh thirth one could be used for living in by the looks of it

 

[Cielian]

I think 3 is honestly more elven.

 

[The Golem]

I feel that #1 is like a castle tower, #2 is a defensive tower, and #3 looks alot more residential

 

[Sven_Tu]

Picked #2 since it seems the most dwarven of the designs.
#3 kinda looks odd in that the top part doesn't look integrated enough with the rest of the design, like it was placed there rather than actually being a part of the tower.
#1 looks better but the wooden sloped roof clashes with the rest of the stone design. Feels more elven or human than dwarf, like something you would see in a forest.

 

[IIIiNSANiTyIII]

Thanks for all of your feedback!

In the end I went with Design number two because that is the one I felt was most dwarven.
Here is the final result!

Long live Torhyeir!

-IIIiNSANiTyIII