Archived Idea For New Ink Sac Custom Recipe

[Legles101]

As many of you probably already know the current Ink Sac recipe is a water bottle surrounded by 4 coal. You cannot stack water bottles this makes it very hard to craft. I see no reason that the water bottle should not be changed to an empty bottle, water bottles are literally free if you have empty bottles, so the actual cost is not much. All this does is waste the players time.

Not only that but I also find it straining to actually have to click around so much just to get a few stacks, the amount of times the item names of the coal/water bottle/Inc Sac blink while crafting puts too much strain on the eyes. I usually have to take a break while crafting because of this.

I do not think making items harder to get by making them physically harder to craft is a good idea. If Staff thinks Inc Sacs would be too easy to get without this, then I propose that the recipe be changed to 8 coal instead of 4, to coal blocks.

I assume the reason behind making this recipe was that squid spawnrates are not so great anymore, however some players have gone to hunting squids anyway just to avoid using this recipe for the reasons given above. That shouldn't be the case, the recipe should server it's intended purpose and right now I do not think it is.

Feedback is welcome.

 

[Emkaloua]

YES. PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY MAKE IT AN EMPTY BOTTLE. NO HARM DONE, VALUE DOES NOT DECREASE, 1000% MORE CONVENIENT TO CRAFT AND 2000% LESS HOMICIDE-INDUCING FRUSTRATION.

 

[MalkNation]

yes yes guud idea

 

[Riley0628]

I absolutely agree.

 

[Zacatero]

+1

 

[JDgoldvox]

making invisibility potions is also a pain because you cannot stack Nightvision potions

 

[Legles101]

I do not want to use more coal for ink. Squids are still here, yes? It's just flywater, waterbreath perks you need to add and boom badda bing, ink sacs. I'd rather not use up unsustainable resources. It takes time to get coal and it ruins the land to get more rather than scooping water.

Click to shrink...

Coal is an unlimited resource, wood logs can be smelted to make charcoal which can be turned into coal blocks, which can then be turned into regular coal. I also believe this to me the more efficient way of getting coal so I do not think you need to worry about land being ruined. As I said before squid spawnrates are also not as good as they were pre-reset, this recipe is supposed to be a fix for that, but it doesn't do the job well.

I appreciate your input though.

 

[Emkaloua]

The only change we need would simply make it easier to craft squid ink by the stack like every other dye instead of 1 by 1 with hella inventory cramming. It would take away one little click on a block of water, so value would not decrease from the current recipe ingredients, but maybe a little value would be lost simply because people would actually start crafting it. But is that so bad? The recipe is there for a reason. I vote for empty bottles!

 

[Zacatero]

The only change we need would simply make it easier to craft squid ink by the stack like every other dye instead of 1 by 1 with hella inventory cramming. It would take away one little click on a block of water, so value would not decrease from the current recipe ingredients, but maybe a little value would be lost simply because people would actually start crafting it. But is that so bad? The recipe is there for a reason. I vote for empty bottles!

Click to shrink...

So this need to even it out would be necessary if it was a market for people to sell... but the materials in order to craft it are very very common. There isnt really a robust market of people selling ink